Brian’s March Madness—My Wild Prediction

Brian Crout is setting up a tournament of quartet singers over on southerngospelcritique that looks to be great fun for us quartet geeks. I plan to hop over and cast my votes in the coming days. Brian will create head-to-head matchups of tenors, leads, baritones and basses, and whichever one gets the most votes will proceed to the next round. The four who make it all the way to the end are the championship quartet.

As I write this, I have not even seen any of Brian’s selections, and yet already I have a wild guess as to which four singers will ultimately emerge victorious. Feel free to affirm or pooh-pooh me in the comments:

Tenor: David Phelps

Lead: Glen Payne

Baritone: Mark Trammell

Bass: George Younce

What do you think? A pretty good guess?

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “Brian’s March Madness—My Wild Prediction

  1. quartet-man

    I figure George or maybe Tim Riley will get bass. Baritone is probably Trammell, but who knows? Glen is a good candidate for lead as well. English has inspired a lot of people as has Guy Penrod, so one of them could have a chance or maybe Ivan Parker.

    Phelps has a really good chance on tenor, but I am wondering if a more “southern gospel” tenor will get it. Contenders might be Funderburk, Haase, or maybe even Free.

    1. I think the only baritone that could have a reasonable chance of upsetting Trammell is Doug Anderson. And last time I saw the two of them being compared, folks were saying “Doug is good, but I’m taking Mark.”

      I think Glen may have a better chance than somebody like Michael English, because he’s a more controversial vocalist. But we’ll see.

      Funderburk is plausible on tenor. Of course I would like to see Haase win, but we’ll see.

      It would be very interesting if the Funderburk/Trammell configuration of the Cathedrals just ended up BEING the championship quartet!

      1. David Mac

        Depends if you voting for “four flat footed guys” or four individuals?

        Personally I think there should be two streams, past and present. Why compare newly started guys- like Aaron McCune with dead legends? It stifles their appeal!!

        I don’t know about MT; Doug gets my vote for baritone, and I would put Marsh next. However, for my ‘all time’ group I would have Glen as BARITONE and Guy as LEAD, Bobby Clark as 1st TENOR, and George as BASS!

      2. I don’t know, I think it’s kind of exciting to have the legends and new-comers in the same boat.

        I plan to vote for Doug myself (assuming he will be one of the ones Brian picks, can’t imagine why not). However, Mark is so enduringly respected and popular that I think in the end he’ll get the most votes.

        You mean you wouldn’t have Ernie as tenor for your all-time? 😮

      3. quartet-man

        Yeah, you are right in that Doug could be a contender. I would still vote for Mark. That guy is a beast or maybe a robot.

  2. pastorjohn

    Hate to say it but, for a lot of people, it gets down to a popularity contest. I would love to see Ernie Haase win, but too many people don’t like him so I doubt it will ever happen. And I agree with David Mac that when you try to compare “legends” who have died with current singers, it just isn’t a level playing field.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s